Rysbek
Positioning: why customers choose you
Coffee on the way to work and a café for meeting a friend serve different needs. How to choose a brand position and support it through your product, service and everyday decisions.
On your way to work in Bishkek, you buy coffee from the place that gets your order out quickly. On Saturday, you meet a friend somewhere you can sit comfortably without being hurried along. And when you want to try an unusual bean, you go to the barista who can spend half an hour talking about processing and roasting.
All three businesses sell coffee. But the reason for choosing each one is different. That difference is where a useful conversation about positioning begins.
Positioning defines who a brand should be the preferred choice for, in what situation, against which alternatives, and for what reason. It is a decision that shapes the product, service, price and communication.
01/ A place in the customer's mind
Customers rarely study an entire market. They usually have a few familiar options and an impression of each: this one is affordable, this one is quiet, this one knows its coffee.
A business can deliberately work to shape that impression. But the position it chooses and the way people actually see it do not always match. Writing “fast coffee” on a sign will not make the service fast. Calling something “premium” does not explain why it is worth paying more for.
Two questions make a useful starting point: what do people already associate with our name, and what expectation that matters to them can we consistently meet?
For a morning coffee stop, predictability might be the most useful association. Customers know they can get their usual drink and continue their journey on time. The value comes from a combination of speed, location, a clear menu and a consistent result.
02/ The customer's task defines the competition
For someone who needs a boost before work, the alternatives to a coffee shop might include a coffee machine at home, a drink from a convenience store or coffee at the office. For someone meeting a friend, the alternatives could be a bakery, a restaurant or a walk.
The competitive set depends on the circumstances of the choice. Looking only at nearby coffee shops can mean missing the alternatives customers are actually weighing up.
It helps to reconstruct a specific purchase: where was the person going, what did they need, which options did they consider, and why did they settle on one? “I like good coffee” gives you less to work with than “I had seven minutes before my bus, and I knew how long the order would take here.”
03/ Making the differences visible
A positioning map places offers along two dimensions. Its usefulness depends on whether those dimensions matter to customers and meaningfully distinguish their options.
For this teaching example, we will use the type of visit and the degree of coffee specialisation. These are separate questions: is the place designed for a quick purchase or a longer stay, and how central is coffee to its offer?
An illustrative map, not market research. The points represent fictional formats; their coordinates are not based on customer data. The upper-right area does not imply better quality or a stronger commercial position.
A format can be delivered in different ways. A particular bakery may take coffee very seriously, while a small coffee shop may encourage people to stay for hours. On a real map, the placement needs to be checked against both the business's offer and customers' perceptions.
An empty area needs investigation too. It may reveal an unmet need. Or it may represent a combination that few people want, or one that is too expensive to deliver. A map helps you ask a question; it does not answer it for you.
04/ A position needs decisions that work together
Suppose a coffee shop chooses to focus on people rushing to work in the morning. It wants to become a reliable way to get a familiar drink without unnecessary waiting.
That choice sets requirements for the business. It needs a short, clear menu, preparation for the morning rush, straightforward payment and consistent drink preparation. Pre-ordering might help. Even a small delay matters when saving time is the reason someone chose the place.
A long breakfast menu, elaborate individual presentation and large tables may put pressure on the operation in ways that undermine that purpose. Each addition needs to be judged by whether it supports the chosen offer and whether the team has the resources to deliver it.
Deliberate limits are especially important for a small business. You cannot serve every situation equally well when they require different processes and compete for the same limited resources.
This does not rule out expanding the audience or the range. But expansion should account for the value the business risks weakening for its existing customers.
05/ Writing a position the team can use
For internal work, it helps to write a short description of who you serve, when they need you, the category you belong to, the value you offer and the evidence that supports it.
For our fictional coffee shop, it might read like this:
For people rushing to work in the morning, we are a coffee stop on the way where they can reliably get their usual drink. A short menu and preparation for the morning rush help us deliver that promise. We measure order times during peak hours.
That last sentence requires actual measurement. If the team does not yet know how long service takes, speed remains a hypothesis to test. A specific time promise should come after the business has demonstrated that it can keep it.
The working statement helps the team make decisions. Customers may experience its meaning through a shorter message, an easy order or a familiar service rhythm. They do not need to read the strategy document.
For a business in the Kyrgyz Republic that serves customers in both Kyrgyz and Russian, there is another practical check: does the same reason to choose you come through in both languages? The words do not have to be literal translations. The promise, and the experience that supports it, should remain consistent.
06/ Testing it on an ordinary working day
Positioning becomes useful when it helps answer practical questions. What should we add to the menu? What should we improve first? Who should we hire? What should our advertising say? Which opportunity should we turn down?
It also needs to be tested against customer behaviour. Do people understand the offer, consider it among their alternatives and choose it for the expected reason? What happens after the first purchase? Price, availability, seasonality and other factors also affect sales, so one metric cannot give a complete assessment of the strategy.
If customers return because they can rely on the speed, and the team can sustain it as demand grows, the position has a real foundation. The next step becomes clearer: strengthen the value people already choose you for, and find other situations where that value matters.
Further reading:
- Al Ries and Jack Trout, Positioning: The Battle for Your Mind.
- April Dunford, Obviously Awesome.
- Philip Kotler and Kevin Lane Keller, Marketing Management.